How a Dollar Will Be N160 in Nigeria: A Blueprint for Economic Resurgence
Dr. Ahmed Adamu
Monday 26 February 2024
How a Dollar Will Be N160 in Nigeria: A Blueprint for Economic Resurgence
Wednesday 14 June 2023
Single Exchange Rate in Nigeria: Conditions and Process
In 1985, one Naira was equivalent to one dollar. In 2023, one dollar equals N760, representing a 75,900% Naira depreciation in just 38 years. In the previous eight years, Naira depreciated by 265%. Based on the trend, the dollar may keep increasing towards N1000 per dollar if nothing is done.
One of the fiscal actions to stabilize the exchange rate is to reduce government foreign spending. The cost of governance should be reduced. Dollarization within government institutions should be reduced as well. Fixing the dollar issues is solving Inflation. All exchange rate policies fix the inflation problem.
Ahmed Adamu,
PhD
Petroleum
Economist
ahmadadamu1@gmail.com
Wednesday 31 May 2023
Finally, Petroleum Subsidy is Gone: The Implications
The final removal of petroleum subsidy in Nigeria is a welcome development. It means the market will determine the fuel price, i.e., willing buyer, willing seller price. It also means that many companies can import petrol and sell it at a price they want to recover their costs and make a profit.
Many suppliers will be posting their market prices. We will see variations in posted prices by companies—no more regulated prices by the government.
The petrol price will fluctuate periodically as crude oil prices and dollar exchange rates change. NNPC Limited and other importers will post their prices whenever there is a change in the variables that affect the cost of their fuel. These could be the distance from which the fuel is imported, its quality, or variation in profit margins.
NNPC Limited posted prices will be the benchmark for the petrol market because it is a fairer and stronger player.
Prices will be coming down in the event of lower crude oil prices. However, there could be collusion by the importers to stick to a higher price even at a low crude oil price. But, higher prices attract more supply, and less demand, leading to excess supply, which brings prices down.
When the Dangote refinery starts operation, the petroleum products importers will then buy from the local refiner, thereby saving the extra costs of distance transportation costs and foreign inflation from the source country. They will be able to reduce their posted prices then.
The marketers will get Dangote's fuel at least N30 less than the imported fuel per liter. They will enjoy Dangote's economy of scale (producing more at cheaper costs) and local production. This cost-saving could be higher due to cheap labor in Nigeria. However, this does not remove the possibility of some marketers sourcing the product cheaper elsewhere.
Marketers that buy from the Dangote refinery will sell first. And if they can meet the local consumption, those that import expensive fuel will be pushed out of the market.
With the sudden increase in fuel price by more than 170% due to the subsidy removal, the economy will shrink in the short run as productivity reduces. There will be less demand for petrol, and overall spending will decrease. Businesses will lay off staff to cope with the increasing cost of doing business, and general welfare will reduce.
However, there will be new inventions as people start looking for alternatives. They will explore alternative transport systems or fuel or adjust their lifestyle. More business opportunities will emerge from this development. People will now begin to organize collaborative transportation means to share or reduce the cost of transportation per head.
There will be efficiency of demand and reduced wastages, and Unnecessary trips will reduce. There will be fewer cars on the road and reduced carbon emissions. The NNPC Limited remittance to the government will increase because the cost of the subsidy is being removed. This enables the government to do more development projects and borrow less.
Even though the approach by President Tinubu needed to be more systematic, it has minimized the chances of prolonged speculative buying by retailers in the event of scheduling the removal on a designated future date.
However, because of his sudden announcement, there are now excessive supplier surpluses. Retailers of petrol that bought their products at a subsidized price just before the announcement are selling them at higher market prices, causing consumer losses and abnormal profit for the suppliers. That is the immediate effect of such a sudden pronouncement.
For example, a retailer that bought a truck of 45 thousand liters at an ex-depot price of N179 per liter just before the announcement is now selling it at N540 per liter, making a surplus of more than N15 million per truck.
Consumer losses are still inevitable even if a future date of the removal is announced, as retailers will engage in even more speculative buying ahead of the date to hoard as many large inventories as possible, wait for the removal date, and make abnormal profits.
The good news is that many filling stations will open, and long queues will disappear, but consumers will lose. One of the conditions for removing the subsidy is sufficient local refining capacity. With the Dangote refinery, there will be a lower price of about N30 or more per liter compared to the imported one due to the advantage of local production.
The Dangote refinery will reduce Nigeria's import bill because, as of now, imported petroleum products are the biggest bill in Nigeria's import basket. So, the Dangote refinery will reduce the supply of Naira, leading to its appreciation. It will positively affect Nigeria's balance of payment due to the exports of petroleum products by the refinery.
Other countries will also bring their crude oil for refining in Nigeria and pay in dollars, thereby growing the impact of the oil sector on GDP. However, Dangote will buy Nigeria's crude oil in dollars, sell the refined petrol in Naira only to Nigerians, and exchange any desired quantity of the Naira receipts for Dollars at the CBN.
Therefore, from the economic perspective, these two developments favor the economy's growth. They will create new business opportunities and lifestyles. The short run will be challenging, but the long run will be stable.
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Petroleum Economist,
ahmadadamu1@gmail.com
Monday 28 November 2022
Kolmani Oil Discovery: What it means
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Some Nigerians had some euphoria as the game-changing oil
and gas discovery in Kolmani, a Northern Nigerian area, was announced. It is
the first Northern Nigerian proven petroleum reserve, sixty-six years after
petroleum discovery in southern Nigeria. "What does this discovery mean to
us as Nigerians and northerners," someone from the north called and asked
me.
An estimated proven reserve of 1 billion barrels of crude
oil and 500 billion cubic feet of natural gas were found in an oil field that
straddles Bauchi and Gombe states, known as the Kolmani oil field. The
commercial quantity of the oil reserve in this area could increase in the
future.
Anywhere oil is found in Nigeria belongs to the federation.
The only benefits to the host community are the 3% of the oil operating cost in
the area from the preceding year and the constitutional 13% derivation funds to
the state government. The new oil-rich states will benefit from these two
sources.
The 3% is only for the oil-bearing communities; other
non-oil-bearing communities will not benefit from it. At the same time, 13% of
all the revenue generated from the oil produced in the state will go to the
state government. Oil-producing states and their host communities could get
more than N100 billion in a year from these two sources alone.
Other extended benefits to the new oil-rich states could be
direct jobs for high, medium, and small-skilled labor. Already some Indian oil
companies have shown interest in becoming partners in developing the onshore
Kolmani oil fields.
Onshore oil production in Nigeria, like the Kolmani field,
is not attractive to major oil-producing companies. The five major oil
companies operating in Nigeria are divesting from onshore and shallow water oil
fields despite the recent reduction in taxes and royalties in the PIA. Oil
companies prefer deep water oil production to avoid hostilities from restiveness,
vandalism, and insecurity associated with the onshore oil production areas.
Because of what is stated in the PIA relating to the 3% for
host communities, the Kolmani oil production should not experience restiveness
and vandalism. The PIA said, "In any year where an act of vandalism,
sabotage or other civil unrest occurs which causes damage to petroleum and
designated facilities or disrupts production activities within the host
communities, the community will forfeit its entitlement to the extent of the
cost of repairs". Host communities' benefits are now tied to the smooth
running of the oil production in their area.
NNPC limited will be the Kolmani oil and gas concessionaire
and will lift Nigeria's profit oil and gas from the oil field and transfer the
proceeds to the Nigerian Petroleum Upstream commission after deducting its
service cost. However, the profit oil could only be derived after cost recovery
by the developers of the field, known as contractors.
The New Nigeria Development Company (NNDC) is the lease
owner for petroleum mining on the field. But, could NNDC be able to develop
this new oil field? No. NNDC may not have the technical and financial readiness
to develop the Kolmani field yet. Therefore, oil companies must be contracted
to spend millions of dollars and provide technical expertise to develop the
area.
There will not be a profit oil and gas from the field until
after some years of production to allow the contractors to recover their cost,
but this depends on the oil price and contract agreements. Mainly the cost
incurred by the contractor in developing the field is amortized and may take up
to the first five years of production, and then the profit sharing will start.
This is to allow the operators to recover their costs of development. The
government will transfer the exploration costs to the operator, which will add
to the total cost of oil.
The only money that will be accruing to the federation
account in the early years of production will be the royalty crude and
hydrocarbon taxes (only if there is a profit), which are 15% and 30% of the
crude oil produced, respectively. It could take between five to ten years to
develop the field. So, any financial benefits will be after developing the
area.
Would the focus be on developing crude oil only or both
crude oil and gas? Natural gas has far-reaching economic benefits, but
developing it is more expensive. With the ongoing gas pipeline projects, there
could be more gas supply from this field which will help industrial growth in
the country.
Now, some states will begin to suspect their possible oil
and gas reserves. We can now conclude that every part of Nigeria has a possible
oil and gas reserve. With the first oil discovery in the north and with the
creation of the Frontier Exploration Funds, more exploration will be undertaken
in the north. The Frontier Exploration Fund is funded by 30% of the NNPC
Limited profit oil and gas and 10% of all rents on petroleum licenses and
leases.
Many states are facing debt and development issues and might
wish to have more control and access to the natural resources in their states
to fix their problems. More oil, gas, and other natural resources could be
harnessed when state governments are given the right to control those
resources. States will maximize their potential resources to outcompete each
other.
In the event of states' resource control, people ask, how
could border states handle shared oil and gas fields that cross their borders?
Just like the Kolmani oil and gas field, which straddles across Gombe and
Bauchi states. Any state that produces more at the border areas may draw more
oil from the neighboring state. So, who drills first captures the oil.
To avoid
over-production and damage to the environment at the border areas, the
neighboring states should unify the oil field, appoint a single operator, and
share the profit based on where the field lies in relation to the boundary.
State governments in a geo-political zone could undertake this kind of
unification.
Even after states' resource control, further oil
explorations will continue to search for more oil and gas reserves in the
states that do not confirm their petroleum deposits yet. So, non-oil-producing
states could become oil producers eventually.
With oil fading away and growing restrictions on the use of
fossil fuels, we can maximize the utilization of our endowed petroleum
resources to build infrastructure and the economy and fund alternative energy
sources and consumption.
Finally, more oil reserves without growing and functioning
refineries will not make any difference. The focus should be on functioning and
adequate refineries locally to stop importing refined petroleum. Imported
refined petroleum is the biggest bill in our import basket. Having local
refineries will help restore the value of our exchange rates. Government
refineries must be privatized as soon as possible, and modular refineries
should be encouraged to grow their efficiencies and capacities. So, the
discovery of oil and gas in the Kolmani area is not a given benefit; it is a
potential benefit, so celebrate not yet.
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Petroleum Economist
ahmadadamu1@gmail.com
Wednesday 8 June 2022
How Subsidy Removal on Diesel causes Scarcity and High Price of Petrol in Nigeria.
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Wednesday 20 April 2022
Big Economic Crisis Looms in Nigeria
Sunday 20 February 2022
Fuel Scarcity: Issues and Solutions
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Wednesday 26 January 2022
The Petroleum Subsidy Trap and The Way Forward
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
Sunday 19 December 2021
How to urgently fix insecurity in Northern Nigeria
- Ahmed Adamu,
PhD
Since the recent exacerbation of terrorism in northern
Nigeria, there have not been serious legal actions to punish the culprits.
There should be an emergency court for trying the criminals and immediately
convict them.
There should be a special law that dictates the kinds of
punishment for every kind of complicity in banditry and kidnapping. The
punishment should be severe and in the public view. It will serve as a
deterrent to others who might be tempted to be involved in any kind of
terrorism.
The government cannot fix this level of insecurity in a
short while, that is why the citizens have to come in. For northern Nigeria, there should be an
independent body or forum that will unite the expertise and resources of all
active and retired professionals and elites from the region.
The forum will be independent of the government and should
have a structure down to the local government levels. It will be managed by
highly respected and experienced people in the region. The forum might be named
“Arewa Development Forum”.
The forum will feed the various state governments
individually and as a group with ideas and strategies and help harmonize their
approaches toward combating the insecurity.
The body will establish “The Arewa Development Trust Fund”,
where every working and capable northerner will be contributing a willing
amount of money monthly. The funds will be used for compulsory education for
all and some basic infrastructural development in the northern rural areas.
The extent of the abject poverty in the north is
unimaginable. There are still villages where they don’t have schools and no
access to electricity. These villages have no road and potable water, and their
population is growing.
The Arewa Funds will be used to build infrastructure in
these kinds of villages. It will be used to build schools and sponsor every
child’s education, especially in remote areas. It will be used for free
education for every northerner. New teachers will be trained and recruited and
paid well from the funds.
The Funds should be used to address street children begging
and hawking. The Forum will conduct a census of the “Almajiri Child” for a
database of their locations and their homes of origin, with a plan to send
every child back to their parents.
The parents should be incentivized for keeping and
supporting their children's education. The Funds can also be used to support
modern and mechanized farming, including animal rearing and ranches. It can
also be used for capital seed for women's entrepreneurship and businesses.
All the international donor agencies and NGOs that want to
work in Northern Nigeria should work with the Arewa Development Forum. The idea
is to harmonize the resources for efficiency, devoid of duplication.
The governments of all the northern states should contribute
to the funds. International Organizations and Foundations should be solicited
to contribute to the Funds. The idea is to generate and spend at least N2
trillion for only education and basic infrastructure in rural areas of the
region.
If we can have up to ten million northerners who will be
contributing at least N20,000 every month, we will raise N2.4 trillion in a
year.
On top of this, we can receive donations from the state
governments, NGOs and international agencies, and foundations. Nigerians in the
southern region might wish to contribute as well.
The local government branches of the Forum should maintain
education and development statistics and a database of the people under their
jurisdiction. The information will help for the appropriate allocation of these
resources.
There should be a new law that will convict any person or
their parent for not acquiring a minimum of secondary school education in the
North. The Education must be compelled and made free for all.
Banditry and all kinds of terrorism are ideologies.
Ideologies are groomed by certain circumstances, and they can travel
everywhere. The only thing that prevents it is education.
Only education and empowerment can fix insecurity. If we
don’t come together to kill this ideology, it will kill us. It is now time to
stop expecting too much from the government. We have to rise and do it
ourselves.
It is not surprising that Northern Nigeria is facing this
level of insecurity because despite being the region with the highest
population growth rate (with an average woman giving birth to six children),
more than half of the girl children aged six and above are not having an
education.
The region also accounts for 9 million of the 14 million
out-of-school children in Nigeria, with the northwest alone having five million
of them. Northern Nigeria's poverty rate is put at 86%. Any region that has a
high level of poverty and lack of education like this has fulfilled the
conditions for insecurity.
Traditional rulers have to be actively involved in
information and intelligence gathering. They are closer to the people; they
could provide relevant information and strategies unique to their territories.
War should be declared in the affected areas. A large number
of Nigerian armies should be deployed and given the order to clear the
terrorists and ensure peace in the region.
Ultimatum could be given to some of the terrorists who are
willing to lay down their arms unconditionally, beyond this chance should be
death. There should be immediate rebuilding and infrastructural development of
the areas where these bandits come from so that they will have options of a new
life in their towns or face death.
Finally, the APC administration must fix insecurity before
the 2023 elections, because the APC and President Buhari were voted mostly to
fix insecurity. The next administration should not inherit another insecurity
challenge.
The next administration should focus on addressing other
issues. We cannot afford to waste a complete eight-year tenure of an ex-Army General
without addressing insecurity in Nigeria.
I call on all Nigerians to take responsibility and act, we
should stop relying absolutely on the government to fix insecurity.
If you do have other ideas on how to fix insecurity or you
want to respectfully challenge or support my submissions above or my previous
article on the subject matter, you can send me an email.
Ahmed Adamu, PhD
ahmadadamu1@gmail.com